WTF
It’s the holiday season and I say this in its broadest sense because the real holiday is Christmas and New Year. The addition of Hanukkah, because it happens at the same time, is nice but really incidental in the timing because it is nothing but just another example of the infestation of political correctness. The importance of Hanukkah which is about a so-called miracle involving lamp oil, has to do with the Maccabean war which was about 170 years before the birth of Jesus Christ. It pales in comparison in its importance.
Be that as it may, I have 2 questions about Christmas and it has little to do with religion but more with aspects of its celebration.
1) I love all the fun stuff about Xmas trees, decorations and Santa Claus. What I don’t understand is the role of penguins in the various decorations. If Santa Claus is from the North Pole, with his reindeer and all that, what the heck have penguins to do with all this???? Penguins can be found only at the South Pole – in Antarctica! There are no penguins at the North Pole. Does anybody know anything about geography? Apparently not.
2) Every year at this time, we go to see Handel’s Messiah at various concert halls in New York. This is also a bit of a puzzle since Handel wrote this oratorio for Easter – not Christmas
But that’s OK, I LOVE IT ANY TIME of the year. What I don’t understand, and perhaps this is also just a local New York manifestation where hypocrisy is de rigueur, is the behavior of some people in the audience during the Halleluiah chorus – the one part of this oratorio that gives me goose bumps of thrill.
When the oratorio was first performed before King George II in 1743, the king stood up when the Halleluiah chorus started. Why? Nobody really knows – other than he was probably extremely moved by the piece. Since then it is customary to stand up during the Halleluiah chorus.
Last night at Carnegie Hall, I noticed again a number of people who did not stand up. I find this extremely offensive because it is disrespectful in terms of custom and it is insulting to Christians. I am Jewish, but art is art and an almost 300 year old custom in art deserves to be perpetuated.
Handel’s Messiah is a masterpiece of baroque classical music. The spectacular venue at Carnegie Hall and the performance by the Musica Sacra group should transcend any political or religious views. When 95% of a full house stands up, and you’re sitting down, you’re nothing but either an uncultivated lout, or simply a moron. Whatever these people’s message was, it was lost in the exuberance of the rest of the audience.
Voila! These are my 2 comments about Christmas. See this performance of the Hallelujah chorus by the Mormon Tabernacle Choir. It is the best one I could find on YouTube because you can actually see the 4 voices – the tenors, baritones, sopranos and mezzo-sopranos. And of course, the audience stands up
Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah, Happy New Year!






